Who was Annatar and why did the elves believe in him? (2023)

J.R.R. ella TolkienLord of the RingsIt is a franchise that gave us many answers, but also many questions. Tolkien's history of Middle-earth is simply amazing and there are so many elements we could write about, some of which are more well known while others are completely obscure. In this article, we are going to talk about one of those dark characters, Annatar, and we are going to reveal to you why the elves originally believed in him.

Annatar, the 'Lord of Gifts' was actually an alias for Sauron during the Second Age when he appeared in his fair form and led the elves to create the Rings of Power. He successfully tricked most of the elves, but as soon as he put the ring on, the elves realized his treachery and hid theirs.

The rest of this article will go into more detail on the answer given, as we will give you a more detailed look at Annatar's character and his true identity, as well as the role of Annatar's persona.Lord of the RingsFranchise written by Tolkien. We have gathered all the information you need in one place so that you can get the most out of the article.

Index show

Who was Annatar?

What did the elves think of who Annatar was?

What did Annatar tell Celebrimbor A about the Rings of Power?

(Video) The History of the Three Elven Rings of Power (Why Are They Good?) Artifacts of Arda & ME Explained

Who was Annatar?

Annatar is a character that appeared during the Second Age around the year 1500 CE, although her origins go back even earlier. Some five hundred years after the start of the Second Age, Sauron resurfaces as an admirer of his teacher and begins to emulate him. Little by little he began to prepare himself. He becomes the reincarnation of evil and a being who strives for total power, eventually becoming the "god and lord of men".

That is because he has spent too much time in the East, corrupting the men in his service. Sauron looked at the humans, particularly the smaller humans, who were left behind in Middle-earth compared to those ofnumber, as particularly easy to corrupt. Therefore, he considered the Elves to be the greatest rivals in Middle-earth and therefore decided that it was important to defeat them first in order to gain complete rule.

(Video) The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power - Who is Adar?

Who was Annatar and why did the elves believe in him? (1)

For this reason, Sauron plans to seduce the elves and use them at his service, and for this he takes the form of Annatar, "The Lord of Gifts" and tries to enter Lindon, the greatest kingdom of the elves in Middle-earth. but the elves do not trust him and will not let him in, though he declares himself envoy of the Valar to his aid, particularly as envoy of Aulë, whom the Ñoldor in exile always cherished for their love for him. him for his blacksmithing skills and his ability to create beautiful objects.

So he goes to Eregion, also as an envoy of the Valar, and despite the opposition of Galadriel and Celeborn,Celebrimbor, grandson of Fëanor, who also lived there, lets him in. Annatar befriends Celebrimbor and the Elven Smiths, a brotherhood known as Gwaith-i-Mírdain. He wins their trust by giving them advice and help, teaching them magic and the arts of smithing, of which he, once the chief Maia in the service of Aulë, was very good.

With Annatar's help, the elven smiths forged the rings of power that conferred great power upon their bearers. Annatar then goes to Mount Doom, the great volcano of Mordor, and secretly forges the One Ring: "One Ring to Rule All", whose power was to dominate the other Rings and enslave their bearers to the will of one: Sauron. .

Was Annatar an elf?

No, Annatar was not an elf. The simple fact that he is just another form of Sauron makes it impossible for Annatar to be an Elf, since it was just Sauron in disguise and nothing else. Sauron was an Ainur and therefore not an Elf. But even in his Annatar form, he presented himself as an envoy of the Valar and not an Elf.

What did the elves think of who Annatar was?

Sauron assumed his righteous form and became Annatar. He had to come up with a good story to fool the elves, which was not easy since the elves were very smart and adept at detecting tricks. Using his knowledge of the elves, Annatar decided to present himself as an envoy of the Valar, sent to bring gifts.

His first attempt was a failure as the Lindon elves did not trust him despite his appearance. His story seemed genuine, but they still mistrusted him and wouldn't let him into his kingdom. Even Aulë was not enough to convince the elves, and Aulë was a character held in high esteem by the elves.

RELATED: 30 Most Powerful Characters In The Lord Of The Rings (Ranked)

(Video) Sauron in the First Age | Tolkien Explained

It was only through Celebrimbor's benevolence and resourcefulness that Sauron was able to infiltrate Elven society, though not all elves trusted him. There was strong opposition among the most powerful and influential Elves, which proved correct since Annatar and his story in relation to the Valar turned out to be just a simple joke from Sauron.

Long story short, the Elves thought that Annatar was an envoy from the Valar, but not all the Elves believed this story.

What did Annatar tell Celebrimbor A about the Rings of Power?

Annatar played an important role in the creation of the Rings of Power, though he never actually touched all three Elven Rings. It was Celebrimbor who forged these rings, but Annatar gave him the necessary instructions and information to do so. He told her of the powers the Ring would have and, having already fooled Celebrimbor, he honestly believed that he and Annatar were about to forge something great.

It was only later, when he really felt something was wrong with Annatar, that he withdrew and began to doubt his "friend". After Annatar's identity was revealed, it was Celebrimbor who concealed the remaining Rings of Power, angering Annatar, i.e. Sauron. Because the rings were so powerful, Sauron had to transfer much of his own power from him and create one ring that would rule them all.

RELATED: Why And How Did Sauron Turn Evil In 'The Lord Of The Rings'?

(Video) Sauron in the Second Age | Tolkien Explained (Extended Edition)

As long as he wore the ring, his power would increase, but it would decrease if he didn't wear it. Sauron's plan would have succeeded if the elves had not discovered his influence after the ring was created and placed on Sauron's finger. Then the Elves saw Annatar's Sauron-like nature and knew they had been deceived.

The rings were then removed and left unused while Sauron was in the One's possession. In anger, Sauron declared war and occupied much of Middle-earth. However, the Three Rings of the Elves were forged by Celebrimbor himself without Sauron's direct help, thus free of his evil but connected to the One. Celebrimbor then hid the rings and decided to save them from Sauron by giving them to Gil-galad. , Círdan and Galadriel.

Sauron then attacked Eregion to retrieve all the rings and obtain the rings that had been forged with his help; seven and nine. However, he did not know the destination of the three and wanted to know where they were. He tortured poor Celebrimbor to death on the spot, also slew the rest of Gwaith-i-Mírdain and laid waste to Eregion.

  • Who was Annatar and why did the elves believe in him? (2)

    Arturo S. Poe

    (Video) Adar asks "Who are you?" to Sauron

    Arthur S. Poe is a writer living in Europe. He has a PhD. and speaks five languages. His experience ranges from Alfred Hitchcock films to Bleach, having explored many fictional universes and authors. He is currently focusing on the anime, the childhood love of his, with special attention...


Why did the Elves trust Annatar? ›

Sauron (in his Second Age guise as Annatar) was described as fair, eloquent, and seemingly wise and benevolent. Those elves that trusted him obviously held him in great regard.

What is the meaning of Annatar? ›

name Annatar "Lord of Gifts, *Gift-lord", name assumed by Sauron when he tried to seduce the Eldar in the Second Age (SA:tar).

Was Annatar described as an Elf? ›

It is never specified exactly what they thought he was. He just came there calling himself Annatar, the giver of gifts. He looked very fair and beautiful, and in this form looked just like an elf for the most part. They either would've thought of him as another elf, or maybe even a fair Maia.

Where did Annatar come from? ›

Annatar appeared in Eregion some time around Year 1200 of the Second Age, departing about three hundred years later. That's well before the Fall of Numenor, which during that period was under the rule of Ancalime, Anarion, and Surion. It was over fifteen hundred years later, in 3262, that Sauron was taken to Numenor.

Why is there no Annatar in Rings of Power? ›

The name “Annatar” does not appear in The Lord of the Rings, it's from The Silmarillion. Basically, if it's not mentioned in The Lord of the Rings, Amazon can't use it.

Do Elves get pregnant LOTR? ›

Elves, at least the Eldar, have a pregnancy that lasts about a year. By the age of 1, Elves can speak, walk and dance. Puberty and full height are attained at around their fiftieth to one hundredth year, when they stop aging physically.

What race was Annatar? ›

In Tolkien's stories, Celebrimbor was an elven-smith who was manipulated into forging the Rings of Power by the Dark Lord Sauron, in fair disguise and named Annatar ("Lord of Gifts").

What is an atter? ›

atter (plural atters) (archaic or UK dialectal) Poison, venom, especially of a venomous animal. (archaic or UK dialectal) Pus, corrupt or morbid matter from a sore or wound. (UK dialectal) Epithelium produced on the tongue. (UK dialectal) A scab; a dry sore.

Did Galadriel know Annatar was Sauron? ›

Galadriel was a master of reading hearts, as she showed when the Fellowship showed up and put each one of its members to the test. She also distrusted Feanor, showing foresight. Therefore she either did know Annatar and was not deceived, or she was gone and never met him.

Is elven a female elf? ›

Learned borrowing from Middle English elve, elven (“(also attributively) elf or fairy of either sex”) [and other forms], from Old English elfen, ælfen, ielfen (“female elf”), from elf, ælf, ielf (“elf”) (ultimately from Proto-Germanic *albiz (“elf, fairy”), from Proto-Indo-European *albʰós (“white”)) + -en (suffix ...

Is Annatar the stranger? ›

Speaking about the role to ScreenRant, Weyman said the stranger would go by Annatar. In the interview he touched on the character's importance. Weyman said: “They were pretty clear at the beginning that what they were bringing me was a character who had, at his core, a really deep and primal purpose.

What was Sauron's name when he was an elf? ›

Sauron was the most powerful of the Maiar—primordial spirits created to help the Valar first shape the World. His original name was Mairon, which means "the Admirable," and as an immortal spirit born before the world's creation, he was able to perceive the Creator Eru Ilúvatar directly.

Who was the evil before Sauron? ›

Melkor is the most powerful of the Valar but he turns to darkness and is renamed Morgoth, the primary antagonist of Arda. All evil in the world of Middle-earth ultimately stems from him. One of the Maiar of Aulë betrays his kind and becomes Morgoth's principal lieutenant and successor, Sauron.

Who is the man who fell to Middle-earth? ›

The man who fell to Middle-earth

There is no shortage of theories about the confused celestial traveler known to many as simply the Stranger (Daniel Weyman), or more affectionately as Meteor Man. Some say he is Sauron, or a Balrog, or Tilion — or even Gandalf.

Was Sauron an Elf or a man? ›

In the Second Age, under the guise of Annatar, he deceived the Elves of Eregion, who under his guidance had created the Rings of Power, whilst he secretly forged the One Ring in Mount Doom. Thus Sauron became "the Lord of the Rings".
Page actions.
Physical Description
HeightSee below
17 more rows
Jan 13, 2023

Why can't Gandalf touch the Ring of power? ›

Though someone could start out with good intentions, the Ring would eventually corrupt them. And that is why Gandalf can't touch it. He is afraid that if he did, it would corrupt him and make him just as bad as Sauron since Sauron put so much of himself and his evil into the One Ring.

Is Sauron just an eye? ›

The films insist that Sauron is too weak to take a physical form, and imply that he can only serve as watchful eye over Mordor.

Who has the third elven Ring of Power? ›

The Inverse Analysis — In Tolkien's legendarium, the Three Elven Rings of Power are eventually given to Galadriel, Gil-galad (Benjamin Walker), and Círdan the Shipwright.

What happens when an elf dies? ›

When elves die, their spirits travel to the Halls, where they rest for a time as disembodied shades. Most of them are then returned to corporeal form and rejoin all the other elves living in Valinor.

Can two half-elves have an elf child? ›

Trivia. Half-elves can have children of their own. When they form families with other half-elves, their offspring will be half-elves themselves. However, if a half-elf has children with someone of different ancestry, even a member of their parental races, the results can vary.

How many kids can elves have? ›

Elves typically have four children or fewer. Fëanor and Nerdanel, who had seven sons, were a notable exception. Whenever the Eldar married, whether in youth or in later life, their children were produced within a relatively short time after their wedding.

Are there any black Elves in Middle-earth? ›

While there are not any Black elves in the Lord of the Rings books or films, nothing about Tolkien's source material explicitly precludes a Black elf from existing.

Is elven a race? ›

As a race, Elves are typically depicted as more ancient than humans or other races, mentioned to have flourished in a sort of Golden Age forgotten by other races. That age was often long before other races appeared or were created.

Is the stranger Gandalf or Sauron? ›

There's little doubt that the stranger is none other than Gandalf, as many theories suspected all along. There are several concrete reasons for this, paired with some subtle hints and some homages to the grey wizard of previous adaptations.

What is the synonym of Atter? ›

element, material, thing, affair, business, circumstance, event, incident, job, proceeding, question, situation, subject, topic, transaction, argument, interest, point, sense, theme.

Who is an Affirmant? ›

affirmant (plural affirmants) One who affirms or asserts. (law) One who affirms of taking an oath.

Is UTER a word? ›

Uter- is a combining form used like a prefix representing the word uterus, also known as the womb, where offspring are conceived and gestate in mammals. It is often used in medical terms, especially in anatomy. Uter- comes from the Latin uterus, meaning “womb” and “matrix.” Matrix?

Was Galadriel fooled by Sauron? ›

Galadriel is one of the wisest and perceptive of all the Elves. In the Second Age, she is one of the only people who is not fooled by Sauron, and it is her idea to hide the Rings of Power from Sauron.

Did Sauron have a lover? ›

Thuringwethil was a Vampire herald and mistress of Morgoth's lieutenant, Sauron. During the Quest for the Silmaril, she got caught in the battle between her master, Huan and Lúthien at Tol-In Gaurhoth.
Biographical Information
SpouseSauron (lover)
Lord of the Rings film trilogy
23 more rows

Did Sauron love Galadriel? ›

Now it is important to remember that Galadriel is an incredibly powerful elf that even, in Tolkien's writing, Sauron is afraid of. While romantic feelings are unlikely or questionable at best between the two, it is clear that Sauron does admire Galadriel's power at the very least.

Is an elf a male or a female? ›

The elves of Norse mythology have survived into folklore mainly as females, living in hills and mounds of stones. The Swedish älvor were stunningly beautiful girls who lived in the forest with an elven king.

How tall is an elf? ›

They value and protect others' freedom as well as their own, and they are more often good than not. Size: Elves range from under 5 to over 6 feet tall and have slender builds.

Can a Elf have a baby? ›

To answer the burning question, no, Elf on the Shelf can't have babies.

Who are the 3 strangers in Rings of Power? ›

The three figures who first appeared at the site of the Stranger's meteorite crash are known as The AsceticOpens in new tab (Kali Kopae), The Nomad (Edith Poor), and The Dweller (Bridie Sisson), the group's apparent leader.

Who are the 3 witches in Rings of Power? ›

But the most puzzling characters on Prime Video's The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power—at least to date—may be the three witches in white who are played by Edith Poor, Bridie Sisson, and Kali Kopae. Perhaps it's more accurate to call them cultists or evil-doers.

Who could the stranger be in Rings of Power? ›

As soon as the Mystics realize the Stranger isn't Sauron, they label him an "Istar." With this label, and several other hints throughout the episode and the season, The Rings of Power has all but confirmed that the Stranger is everyone's favorite wizard: Gandalf the Grey.

Who killed Sauron the first time? ›

Isildur took up the hilt-shard of Narsil and cut the One Ring from Sauron's hand, vanquishing Sauron.

Was there a black elf in Lord of the Rings? ›

There are no Black Elves. There are no Latino Elves” in the "Lord of the Rings," such trolls typically try to hide their hatred by arguing that such casting dishonors the source material.

Who killed Sauron the second time? ›

How was Sauron defeated the second time? No one actually killed him, but his forces were defeated by the Last Alliance of Elves and Men, and he was personally brought down by High King of the Noldor, Gil-Galad, and High King of the Númenóreans, Elendil the Tall, both of whom perished in the deed.

Why did everyone trust Sauron? ›

He was considered the “greatest and proudest” of Numenor's kings. Once Sauron won him over personally, Ar-Pharazon's popularity and influence over his people made it easy for most Numenoreans to extend their trust to Sauron as well.

Why did the Elves accept the rings? ›

It was only thanks to Celebrimbor's own secret rings that the elves manage to avoid the same calamitous fate, because although the rings are still linked to Sauron, they were not filled with his malice and hate, but they did still present a channel through which the elves could hear Sauron whispering (similar to how ...

Which humans betray the Elves black clover? ›

The Massacre of the Elf Tribe took place in a secret location within the Forsaken Realm of the Clover Kingdom. Zagred orchestrated the massacre in order to corrupt Licht's four-leaf clover grimoire into a five-leaf clover grimoire that the devil could use.

Why did the Elves want to stay in Middle-earth? ›

In Tolkien's mythology, the Elves under Elrond ultimately decide to remain in Middle-earth in order to help the realms of men. The Valar themselves create the island of Númenor as a reward for humans, but it is destroyed.

Why did Sauron choose an eye? ›

He wasn't truly omnipotent, but his great power allowed him knowledge of many things within the realm. Sauron insisted that the Orcs refer to him as the “Eye” because he did not allow his name to be written or spoken. So when the novels describe the “Eye,” it very well may be a description of Sauron himself.

Did Sauron have a wife? ›

Biographical Information
SpouseSauron (lover)
23 more rows

Is Sauron a man or elf? ›

Page actions
Notable forSmith of Aulë Lieutenant to Morgoth Deceived the Elves into forging the Rings of Power; Created The One Ring; Brought about the Downfall of Númenor; Nearly conquered the whole of Middle-earth
Physical Description
17 more rows
Jan 13, 2023

Which Elves had the 3 rings? ›

With the destruction of Sauron's One Ring in the last years of the Third Age, the Elven-rings also lost their power, including the Three. The Keepers of those Three Rings left Middle-earth together on the White Ship: Galadriel, Elrond and Gandalf, the Keepers of the Three Rings.

Who got the 3 Elven rings? ›

The Inverse Analysis — In Tolkien's legendarium, the Three Elven Rings of Power are eventually given to Galadriel, Gil-galad (Benjamin Walker), and Círdan the Shipwright.

Can Elves Only Love Once LOTR? ›

Monogamy is practised and adultery is unthinkable. By their very nature, they are "seldom swayed by the desires of the body" or influenced by lust. They marry only once for it was ruled by Manwë that, "'since the Elves are by nature permanent in life within Arda, so also is their unmarred marriage.

Is Asta half elf? ›

it seems like Asta is Half ELF and HALF human... that is why we only able to see half part of him become demon. I wanted to know this too and come to think of it that Tetia's element is wind and her child is not known if it is twin or not having a very large possibility that Yuno is also her child.

Is Asta a royal? ›

After turning 15 years old, Asta receives a five-leaf clover grimoire with an Anti Magic devil inside. He joins the Clover Kingdom's Black Bull squad of the Magic Knights and becomes a 1st Class Senior Magic Knight and temporarily a Royal Knight.

Why is the bird always following Asta? ›

While Secre initially only followed Asta because of his grimoire, she grows to genuinely care for him as the series progresses.


1. The Three Elven Rings of Power | Tolkien Explained
(Nerd of the Rings)
2. Sauron in the Second Age | Tolkien Explained
(Nerd of the Rings)
3. Who is Sauron? - The History of the Dark Lord from LotR in Tolkien's Lore (Spoilers)
4. Sauron the Shapeshifter | Tolkien Explained
(Nerd of the Rings)
5. The Mouth of Sauron
(Göksel Köksal)
6. What if Sauron got The One Ring? | Tolkien Theory
(Nerd of the Rings)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Neely Ledner

Last Updated: 04/28/2023

Views: 5263

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (42 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Neely Ledner

Birthday: 1998-06-09

Address: 443 Barrows Terrace, New Jodyberg, CO 57462-5329

Phone: +2433516856029

Job: Central Legal Facilitator

Hobby: Backpacking, Jogging, Magic, Driving, Macrame, Embroidery, Foraging

Introduction: My name is Neely Ledner, I am a bright, determined, beautiful, adventurous, adventurous, spotless, calm person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.